spent a bit of this morning playing songs from the beach boys 'smile' sessions and discussing my interest in the bboys with a friend. i ended up with a model that the beatles were much more of an "outward-facing" group, where the beach boys, actually specifically brian wilson, was a high-watermark of introspection.
my friend remarked that the 'smile' stuff (granted it was never finished officially) and pet sounds before it has great loneliness in it, and a noted lack of something - which we tried to descibe as "cool" and its true, there isn't really any r&b involved in brian's stuff; music doesn't get any whiter. there is something else about "cool" that is not there either, there isn't the feeling that your "getting" something - or being shown something unknown or "hip". even the lyrics to work from "smile" deal with 18th century pioneers and western towns, americana through kalidascopes and breezes, fractured picture puzzles and poems.
the beatles, being english, had a particular sense of humor and distance and sarcasm or irony throughout their records up until the white album. always putting on masks, characters, celebrations, colors, exploring fashion etc with the spiritual or sublime coming via george's interest in india and eventually not working out at all for most of the group ( sexy sadie). brian was seemingly all about something essential and inside and spiritual reaching further and further inward and sidewards with, as the legend goes plenty of grass and acid. just listen to 'our prayer' and the end of 'surf's up'. just listen to 'surf's up' period.
as we talked, i considered the loneliness idea and thought that, in spite of mojo magazine calling 'yesterday' the seed that led to the splitting of the beatles, that the beatles had each other as they moved through the world, changing music. i could be wrong but it seems like brian could have been very very alone as he was creating these projects. imagine, 23 years old, creating Pet Sounds in a studio full of studio pros, arranging and creating the music, knowing you've reached yer limit in regards to your ability with words and hiring collaborators (tony asher with p.sounds and van dyke parks with smile) and meanwhile the record label wants more surf songs and your group thinks you've lost your mind. thanks for the support you bishes.
then there's yer hard ass dad. sheesh.
for the record: brian heard rubber soul - made pet sounds - paul heard that and worked on revolver - brian heard that and was werking on smile when he flamed out as sgt. pepper's was released. both groups taking pop music in directions never seen before, making sounds that others have listened to and copied and will continue to forever.
i should admit that i am usually a big fan of the underdog, and though i don't see this as a competition and understand that the beach boys weren't really underdogs and that wilson probably was wired to implode sooner or later, there is sympathy in me and a wish that this smile stuff was more widely known outside of black framed glasses wearing fools like myself. i just dig it thats all.